Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Brian Ngoma's avatar

This is such a fantastically written article! Absolutely loved reading it from start to finish.

In terms of the use of AI and the preservation of African music and languages...ehhhhhhhhh idk lol. I'm an anti-GenAI absolutist so this very much did challenge a lot of notions I held. What I will say is that I think there is a legitimately earnest attempt to preserve and highlight African art, that's for sure. And I admire the ingenuity to take this growing technology and incorporate it in a way that suits an African context. It's this kind of making much out of not much that has always defined African people.

That being said, I still don't think this is the play. I feel like all the investment that is going into using GenAI as a preservation tool could be better utilized - in an economic, ethical, and cultural sense - by seeking out and/or training actual experts on these languages and forms of music. This is a massive issue with GenAI as is and is especially significant in a context in which African art is already undermined (like why draw so much attention to an AI-generated amapiano album when you could potentially be highlighting up and coming, human talent lmao).

But beyond this, and the part that speaks to the unease described in this article, is that this just feels...wrong. It feels like the AI-generated content that emerges from this feels less like the real thing and more like a hollow facsimile, a mere imitation of African art. Given the importance of the human element of African storytelling - the passing down of indigenous knowledge through oral means, performance, call-and-response, in-the-moment creativity - you can't get that from AI. You can't ask an AI chatbot why these stories matter in the present day. You can't ask an AI chatbot what these stories meant to our ancestors. You can't get the spontaneity and invention that makes these stories what they are. GenAI, at it's absolute best, will still only able to remix what already was. It can't create. It can't innovate. And you can't preserve the past without using it to create the future.

This is long as hell so Tl;dr: Fantastic article, AI still isn't the play imo.

Kenkwe's avatar

This is beautiful and I appreciate how balanced all points of views were and how you explained everything 🧡

No posts

Ready for more?